Rugby World Cup: Are Tier Two nations closing the gap?


Our partners and we use cookies to provide you with the best internet experience, such as to personalise content and advertising. Information on your discussion with this site and the ads shown to you could be shared with all companies.
Please let us know whether you agree.
By Mike Henson
BBC Sport
By expectations that are ordinary, the scoreline didnt look extraordinary.
With 35 minutes one team leading another 10 points to nine was shown by the huge screen at Tokyo Stadium.
However, the team was the lowest-ranked nation taking part in Rugby World Cup 2019, Namibia. Their line-up included a dentist, a bank employee and some farmers . The opposition was championship events New Zealand and the champions.
By exactly the exact same stage in their assembly with Japan from the 1995 championship, the All Blacks had run in 11 tries to direct 77-3 – .
The tale of those 2 snapshots, taken 24 years apart, looks one of a narrowing gap between the match superpowers and wannabes. But is it true?
The international game is, divided by world Rugby, World Cup organisers and the game governing body right into Tier One and Tier Two nations.
Tier One includes the teams at the Six Nations – England, France, Italy, Ireland, Scotland and Wales – and also people who compete at the hemispheres Rugby Championship – South Africa and Argentina, Australia, New Zealand.
Every other state who plays in the World Cup, but is excluded from those annual tournaments that are top notch, is Tier Two.
Outside World Cups, the two groups blend sometimes, with all Tier One nations playing with each other to maximise revenue in a tight Test fixture listing of.
So how have Tier Two nations fared every four years when afforded a place in the table?
While this graph suggests the games minnows are inching closer to taking chunks its a bit more complicated.
The amount of upsets – if a Tier Two nation has managed to turn more than a Tier One marching – has stayed minimal and steady .
What about if we take a look at the near shaves?
Contemplating tournaments because the laws have been changed five points to get a try, Tier two countries have seldom even finished within seven factors – losing bonus point land – or better.
The 2007 tournament, that featured a Tier Two win and three relatively near defeats, remains a highpoint by that yardstick.
In the tournament of this year, the match hassensed than the scoreline suggests. Should we look at each matchs small print?
Following their start against New Zealand at Tokyo, Namibia were swatted 71-9 aside by the All Blacks. The winning margin was higher than when the All Blacks racked up a 58-14 success in the teams 2015 World Cup assembly.
However, Namibia made only 57 yards in hand in 2015, residing land that was 27% and 30% ownership off. Four decades after, and despite the defeat that was thicker, they appreciated land that was 43% and possession and left 302 metres. With every statistic, bar the scoreline, they have been closer to their opponents that are fabled.
In truth, it is might be that World Cups are too rare, making too little a sample size having too many factors to chart a trend that is definite.
The turnaround times between fixtures can skew a result one way or the other. Pool draws can boost a Tier 2 sides chances or shield Tier One teams modesty. One particularly defeat can artificially inflate the average winning margin between Tier One and Tier Two nations overall.
And even World Rugbys own differentiation between Tiers is looking dated. Above Argentina, Fiji and Japan were rated Ahead of the beginning of the tournament while both Georgia and the United States were higher than Italy.
Although some teams do appear to be making certain progress – like Japan, that are ranked seventh before their quarter-final with South Africa – others like Romania, who failed to qualify for the Rugby World Cup for the first time last year, seem to be going in the opposite direction.
World Rugby has committed #60m to help Tier two countries compete at the championship of this year, however it is invested by each country varies.
More frequent chances for the game lights to compete against the elite could clarify, and, according to a lot of coaches, enhance, a intricate picture.
England coach Eddie Jones:You are viewing the tier-two countries better physically ready. We have played against Tonga and America and both of them had bodily packs.
Theyre fitter than they have been and that is a fantastic thing to the World Cup, since weve got these Tier two countries battling hard and its producing some wonderful rugby.
Namibia amount eight Janco Venter:Id rather play the All Blacks every week than play everybody in Africa and triumph from 80 points, If we play with them every week, finally well be aggressive since well continue learning, and keep getting better.
That is certainly something Namibia needs. We need to play bigger countries. Japan did this and that has made them the group theyre now.
Canada coach Kingsley Jones:When I first came to Canada it was a simple check, getting players together, in relation to these holding down day jobs, however the debut of [United States professional national league] Important League Rugby is lifeline for both Canada and USA.
it is a pathway for coaches and players and is providing our players opportunities. It is a large step in the perfect direction. MLR has a thing to do but, if it is a pathway into the top amount of Guru 14, Super Rugby, thats fantastic, and, in the very long term, Im sure it will get up to speed and be good competition itself – and thats crucial.
Russia coach Lyn Jones:It is not another level, it is another sport for Tier Two nations. We have seen great tales from Uruguay and other Tier Two nations who have developed from difficult championships in 2015 and 2011, and were likely to get much better. We have got some excellent players, some gifted players, and now we all look ahead to the near future with some optimism.
Tonga coach Toutai Kefu:We want more games that will bring higher quality time together. We also carry a list. So people are the main things to help people compete.
Everyone can see the progress over the previous 3 weeks, and the past four weeks if youve got the All Blacks closing warm-up match in Hamilton. We have improved from sight.
Uruguay coach Esteban Meneses:Were playing against world-class sides and we all think we could be stronger by playing against these powerful teams
Former England fly-half along with BBC Radio 5 Live summariser Paul Grayson:Theres no wonder the Tier Two countries have definitely improved. The blow-outs of the past havent occurred.
Grade Two countries demand more exposure to Tier One teams with a more cohesive fixture record – that is a potential alternative, but some of the core traditional teams from the northern hemisphere appear reluctant to permit that.
Statistical analysis and insight from Russ Petty.
Support for Gregor Townsend isdraining and his coaching staff areon trial following Scotlands Rugby World Cup leave, writes Tom English.
Cassie Maddox and detectives Rob Reilly investigate a kids murder
Trash discussion fresh stars burning nation-uniting and bright triumphs – just how much do you remember of those legendary Rugby World Cup minutes?
Get headlines and scores delivered to your phone, and also learn where to locate us on internet.
The way to get into rugby union – through the age groups up to the 15-player game or attempt rugby sevensthat made its Olympic debut in 2016.
Analysis enjoy the very best discussion and interviews with BBC 5 live and World Service and our rugby union comment listings.

Read more here: